An impoverished 69-year-old man is diagnosed with cancer of the

An impoverished 69-year-old man is diagnosed with cancer of the pancreas. There is no hope for cure, but radiation and chemotherapy, which could cost more than $150,000, may extend his life for a few months. If this patient unambiguously requests treatment, his doctors may struggle with the decision but will probably provide the treatment, ignoring the cost as a matter of principle.

On the other hand, a health department — or a hospital — proposes an action that would prevent many cases of some forms of pancreatic cancer. It could be offering free education on the effects of alcohol on the pancreas.

In both instances, health experts must make tough decisions that entail weighing the costs of an action against its benefits in extending human life. Why is the value of extending human life the determining factor in the first example and the cost of the intervention the determining factor in the second? These two scenarios expose tangled issues of ethics, cost, and cost-effectiveness and highlight a troubling structural bias against prevention.

Many people reject any attempt to put a dollar value on human life. From such a perspective, any withholding of potentially life-extending interventions on the basis of their costs is unethical. But within every organization and throughout society, limits on funding make it impossible to pay for every conceivable intervention. That reality forces health leaders to make painful decisions about what to pay for.

In your paper:

  1. Discuss this scenario in respect to ethics, cost and cost-effectiveness.
  2. What should a physician do in this case?
  3. If the treatment is refused, how would you go about finding a way to obtain treatment for this man?

Length: Submit a 3-page paper.

Expert Solution Preview

Introduction:
The scenario presented raises important ethical dilemmas that healthcare providers often face. These dilemmas arise when the costs associated with a medical intervention for a patient’s ailment or preventative measures for the general population are weighed against the benefits. In both instances, healthcare providers must make a difficult decision, keeping in mind the Hippocratic Oath of “first, do no harm” and their fiduciary responsibility towards their patients.

1. Discuss this scenario in respect to ethics, cost, and cost-effectiveness.

In cases where a patient is diagnosed with an incurable ailment, healthcare providers must weigh the benefits of interventions, both in terms of extending the patient’s life and their quality of life, against the costs associated with the intervention. In this case, the doctors must evaluate if the extension of the patient’s life by a few months is worth the cost of $150,000. This ethical debate is accentuated when healthcare providers endeavor to extend human life without regard to the patient’s quality of life or the financial implications for the patient.

While the first scenario involves the treatment of an individual patient, the second scenario is about preventing the onset of a disease in multiple individuals. The healthcare providers must evaluate if an investment in preventative measures, such as offering free education on the effects of alcohol on the pancreas, would be more beneficial than the treatment of an individual. An investment in preventative measures is often seen to be cost-effective in the long run, with significantly reduced costs later, as individuals are able to avoid the disease altogether.

2. What should a physician do in this case?

The physician must prioritize the best interest of the patient while keeping in mind the cost-benefit analysis of the intervention. In this case, they must have a transparent conversation with the patient about the costs of the intervention versus its benefits. The physician should also inform the patient about alternative treatments that may be more cost-effective and inquire if the patient has any financial constraints. Physicians must keep in mind that they have a fiduciary responsibility to their patients to provide the best possible care, but the implementation of this responsibility may be limited owing to the financial constraints that exist within the healthcare system.

3. If the treatment is refused, how would you go about finding a way to obtain treatment for this man?

If the patient refuses treatment, the physician must respect their decision, but they must also inform the patient that they are willing to explore other treatment options that might be more cost-effective. The physician should discuss the patient’s medical history, if any, and determine if they qualify for any clinical trials or research studies. The physician should also attempt to verify if there are any financial resources available to the patient, such as community or government programs that may cover a portion of the treatment cost. If all else fails, the physician should provide the patient with a referral to a financial counselor who can provide advice on how to pay for medical treatment.

Conclusion:

As healthcare providers, our foremost responsibility is to provide the best care possible to our patients. While cost and cost-effectiveness should not be the sole factors in treatment decisions, they should be considered as contributing factors. In the cases where the cost of medical intervention is too high for an individual patient, healthcare providers must seek alternative treatments and financial resources that may be available. In the long term, preventative measures, such as increased education on ongoing health risks, may be more cost-effective than the treatment of patients after they fall ill.

#impoverished #69yearold #man #diagnosed #cancer

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Late Submission Policy This assignment is subject to the Late

  Late Submission Policy This assignment is subject to the Late Submission penalty policy, namely 5% per day for three days. This page will close and will not allow further submissions after this Late Submission period has expired. In the event of an emergency situation preventing you from submitting within

Review at least 2 academically reviewed articles on capital budgeting

  Review at least 2 academically reviewed articles on capital budgeting and 2 articles on financial analysis and complete the following: A. Write an annotated bibliography of each article. B. Based on the articles you reviewed, discuss what you learned C. In addition, discuss how a manager would use the

Big data is the vast collection of multiple data outlets

Big data is the vast collection of multiple data outlets combined into a singular, massive storage space of data (Thew, 2016). As part of a clinical system, big data is beneficial for many reasons, but the largest—and most important reason—may simply be the benefit of improving patient care. Specifically, big

DQ 1: Tobacco is a racial justice issue In April

DQ 1: Tobacco is a racial justice issue In April 2021, the FDA has announced that it will ban menthol cigarettes and flavored cigars within the next year, a move the tobacco industry has pushed against for the last decade. According to acting FDA commissioner Dr. Janet Woodcock, “With these

1. Discuss the five types of Hepatitis in terms of

  1. Discuss the five types of Hepatitis in terms of etiology, symptoms, treatment, and prevention. 2. Discuss is the difference between the etiology and symptoms of cholelithiasis and cholecystitis. Can a person have cholelithiasis and cholecystitis at the same time? How can cholelithiasis and cholecystitis affect the liver and

Discussion Forum- Drugs and the Nervous System Discussion Topic Discussion:

Discussion Forum- Drugs and the Nervous System Discussion Topic Discussion: What is the relationship of neurogenesis to Alzheimer’sdisease? What are some implications of this relationship for future mentalhealth research? For your peer response replies– Do you agree or disagree with your coursemate’s perspective? What additional suggestions can you offer to

What new insight did you gain after completing this module?

What new insight did you gain after completing this module? What were the most important lessons learned in this module? What was the most difficult point or concept in this lesson? How will you apply the lessons learned in this module in your professional life? Module Contents: – Strategic Maangement

1. List the 4 Aspects of quality that should be

1. List the 4 Aspects of quality that should be included in product descriptions. 2. List 5 ways that quality is applied in the Quality Management Approach. 3. List 6 Benefits of the quality technique.  4. List the 5 steps of the planning approach. 5. What activity is a prerequisite

Prior to beginning work on this discussion forum, watch the

Prior to beginning work on this discussion forum, watch the Week 2 Discussion video with Brenda Forde, CPA, MBA. Next, create a free LinkedIn account using the resource, LinkedIn Alumni Tool for University of Arizona Global Campus. (Links to an external site.) LinkedIn is considered a powerful job search tool in today’s

You should respond to at least two of your peers

  You should respond to at least two of your peers by extending, refuting/correcting, or adding additional nuance to their posts. Your responses must be substantive and not just agreeing with someone’s work. You need to add by explaining more, refuting a point or correcting a point.  a minimum of 150 words

Diagnostic Technology/Screening Medical

Description The aim of the assignment is to: 1. Identify a diagnostic test, technology or method, and formulate a clinical question; 2. Critically appraise relevant evidence; 3. Ascertain the applicability and relevance to diagnosis and the diagnostic pathway; 4. Discuss, based on the evidence, the clinical context and the implications

PLEASE POST EACH ASSIGNMENT SEPARATELY Assignment 1 Read Chapter 5

  PLEASE POST EACH ASSIGNMENT SEPARATELY  Assignment 1 Read Chapter 5 and Chapter 6 (ATTACHED) Write your reflections by selecting an idea from the reading, describing your thoughts and feelings about it (Total of 1 FULL Pages half-page per Chapter) Assignment 2 Read Chapter 7 and Chapter 8 (ATTACHED) Write your

Topic: Patient Safety In a Hospitalized Setting During the COVID-19

Topic: Patient Safety In a Hospitalized Setting During the COVID-19 Pandemic Articles below Chen, H. Y., Lu, L., Ko, Y. M., Chueh, J. W., Hsiao, S. Y., Wang, P. C., & Cooper, C. L. (2021). Post-Pandemic Patient Safety Culture: A Case from a Large Metropolitan Hospital Group in Taiwan. International

Week 4 Discussion Just as quickly as new technology is

   Week 4 Discussion    Just as quickly as new technology is developed, hackers find new  ways to disrupt operations. As a result, security is an ongoing endeavor  in all organizations. Strategic planning can help organizations be  prepared to address new daily threats to information security.  Moreover, many of today’s organizations are adopting virtualization as

This week you‘re learning some of the characteristics that will

 This week you‘re learning some of the characteristics that will help you practice your relationship building skill (trust, mutual respect, mindfulness, diversity and inclusion, and open communication). Discuss how you are applying at least one of these characteristics in your life right now at home, work, or school. 

Public health: Oral health program

Based on current concepts/issue facing Dental Public Health, the student is to select a concept/issue of their choice and design a public health program to meet the oral health needs of an identified population. Address the areas of the multidisciplinary health team, cultural and linguistic competency, advocacy, and workforce models

HIM 495 AU Respiratory Therapist Professional Practice Essay Nursing Assignment Help

This assignment will focus on what you learned and applied in the Health Information Management program and what your learned during your professional practice experience. In your paper, Differentiate between the AHIMA Code of Ethical Standards you used during your professional practice experience. Determine how you applied knowledge, skills, and