Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

Ethical Considerations Read the assigned article, “Informed Consent for Emergency

April 8, 2022

Ethical Considerations

Read the assigned article, “Informed Consent for Emergency Contraception: Variability in Hospital Care of Rape Victims.”

Review the Brownfield v. Daniel Freeman Marina Hospital case summary. (Below)

Review Requirements. (Below)

Brownfield v. Daniel Freeman Marina Hospital

Ascension Health (2007) Brownfield v. Daniel Freeman Marina Hospital. Retrieved November 28, 2008 from

http://www.ascensionhealth.org/ethics/public/cases/cases_AF.asp

In this 1989 federal appellate court case, the plaintiff was taken to Freeman Hospital’s emergency room after being raped. In response to the patient’s request for information about the morning-after pill, the hospital authorities refused to provide such information, believing that they could not, on the grounds that it was a Catholic hospital. Specifically, the hospital did not inform the patient that if she wanted such treatment it must be obtained within 72 hours to be effective. The court reasoned that a patient has the right to make her own decisions regarding treatment, and therefore, adequate disclosure of information must be provided so the patient can make an informed decision. The court concluded that a rape victim who is denied information about access to the morning-after pill may bring a medical malpractice action. This means that liability may arise if the patient can show: 1) that a skilled practitioner would have provided such information and access under similar circumstances; 2) that she would have elected such treatment; and 3) that “damages” (in this case, pregnancy) resulted from the failure to provide such information. In a footnote to its decision, the court indicated that “access” to such treatment could include transfer of the patient to another medical facility or another physician.

More critical for Catholic-sponsored hospitals, the court also reasoned that the morning-after pill constitutes the “prevention” rather the than “termination” of pregnancy. It therefore concluded that the conscience clause under the state’s abortion statute did not immunize the hospital from liability for failure to refuse to provide such information. However, since human life begins at conception (fertilization) and not merely after implantation of the embryo, the relevant moral question from the Catholic perspective is not whether or not there is a pregnancy, but whether or not there is another innocent human life to be respected. Those “contraceptive” measures that operate solely through the prevention of implantation are morally equivalent to abortions in Catholic moral theology, and are therefore impermissible under the Ethical and Religious Directives (both then and now). Nevertheless, the court did not accept this moral distinction as relevant for its ruling.

The court ruling itself stated that Catholic Hospitals have the responsibility “to provide information concerning, and access to, estrogen prophylaxis for rape victims.”

Requirements:

You are to complete a 1-2 page (12 pt Times New Roman font, double spaced) issue analysis that answers the following questions:

What are the ethical considerations of this issue?

What are the legal considerations of this issue?

What ethical concepts and principles apply to this issue?

If you were a judge in the Brownfield v. Daniel Freeman Marina Hospital case, would you agree with the other judge’s decisions? How would you justify this decision to the hospital or the rape victims?

Your submission is to be a formal, multi-paragraphed. While citations and sources are not required for this paper, if you borrow any information as supporting details, they must be cited in proper APA format.

HSM Week 6 Ethical Considerations

HSM Week 6 Ethical Considerations

Criteria Ratings Pts

INSTRUCTIONS AND REQUIREMENTS Requirements: 0 pts 0 pts

You are to complete a 1-2 page (12pt Times New Roman font, Full No

double spaced) issue analysis that answers the following Marks Marks

questions: 1. What are the ethical considerations of this issue?

2. What are the legal considerations of this issue?

3. What ethical concepts and principles apply to this issue?

4. If you were a judge in the Brownfield v. Daniel Freeman

Marina Hospital case, would you agree with the other judge’s 0 pts

decisions? How would you justify this decision to the hospital or

the rape victims? Your submission is to be a formal, multi-paragraphed.

While citations and sources are not required for this paper,

if you borrow any information as supporting details,

they must be cited in proper APA format.

Spelling and Grammar 10 to >0.0 pts 0 pts
Full Marks No Marks 10pts

Page Length: 1-2 Pages 12 pt Font 10 to >0.0 pts 0 pts
Full Marks No Marks 10pts

Content: Addresses all 4 of the required questions 20 points 80 to >0.0 pts 0 pts

per question Full Marks No Marks

1. What are the ethical considerations of this issue?

2. What are the legal considerations of this issue?

3. What ethical concepts and principles apply to this issue?

4. If you were a judge in the Brownfield v. Daniel Freeman Marina 80 pts

Hospital case, would you agree with the other judge’s decisions?

How would you justify this decision to the hospital or the rape victims?

Your submission is to be a formal, multi-paragraphed.

While citations and sources are not required for this paper,

if you borrow any information as supporting details,

they must be cited in proper APA format.
Total Points: 100

Share This Post

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Describe your acculturation experience as a new graduate to the

Describe your acculturation experience as a new graduate to the culture of the nursing profession. How is it similar or different from the acculturation experience of a new nursing colleague who joined your team within the past year? Submission Instructions: Your initial post should be at least 500 words, formatted, and

Assignment Week 3 Instructions Grade weight Each Assignment is worth

Grade weight Each Assignment is worth 6% of your total grade. Course Objectives: Discuss the role of e-Business in practical business applications Identify techniques and tools that can be used to evaluate the driving forces of e-Business Assess e-Business influence on businesses and how it provides a competitive advantage Prompt:

Security in fast-food chain company

A large, fast-food chain unveiled a new touch screen register for its franchises. Each cashier was assigned a user id and password combination to log in to the register. The system allowed the incorrect password to be entered four (4) times before the register would lock and require a manager

need a employee handbook created. Topic think as if you

need a employee handbook created. Topic think as if you was starting a business create a employee handbook for your workers with the following involved : Company’s mission EEO policy Hours of work Paid holidays Annual leave, vacation leave, sick leave, bereavement leave, military leave, etc Compensation Diversity Training Benefits

Writing about the creation of Mona Lisa painting and the

Writing about the creation of Mona Lisa painting and the history or Leonardo da Vinci . Breaking down the realism of painting it took him 10 years to finish her lips on painting giving inner concept of painting even though it looks like a woman just sitting for a painting

Attached document has info on organization Consider your current organization

Attached document has info on organization Consider your current organization that you are working for or the one you have worked for in the past. Suppose you are charged with a systems analysis project within your department and you decide to use the traditional methods of requirements gathering, in a

Instructions This assignment focuses on demand, supply, and equilibrium. Let’s

Instructions This assignment focuses on demand, supply, and equilibrium. Let’s start with the basics. Begin your assignment by providing the following information. Explain the difference between a movement along demand and supply curves and a shift of demand and supply curves. What can cause the above situations? Provide an example

Effective evidence based teaching strategies allow learners to collaborate with peers and participate in higher order thinking Question Nursing Assignment Help

Expert Solution Preview Introduction: As a medical professor responsible for designing college assignments and assessments for medical college students, I have the privilege of shaping their educational journey. My role includes creating lecture materials, evaluating student performance through exams and assignments, and providing constructive feedback to foster their learning and

1-Complete a presentation articulating both the unique nature of occupation

1-Complete a presentation articulating both the unique nature of occupation as viewed by the profession of occupational therapy and the value of occupation to support participation in context for the client. 2-Explain the role of sociocultural, socioeconomic, and diversity factors, as well as lifestyle choices in contemporary society on occupation

In a 5-6 page paper, Imagine that you are a

In a 5-6 page paper, Imagine that you are a departmental manager in a large health care organization’s information technology (IT) department. The chief information officer (CIO) has asked you to initiate a change from the traditional waterfall project structure to an agile approach. Complete the following for this

choose a single business to pursue together. Identify the segment

choose a single business to pursue together. Identify the segment of your potential customers that would be early adopters. This should be a group of people to whom you can communicate your product or service offering through some method of direct contact. The group needs to be significant in numbers

NUS201 LPN to RN Transition – Theory Nursing Assignment Help

must analyze a pre-selected article with respect to Roy’s Adaptation Model (RAM) and write a Paper discussing the impact of RAM on care. (Choose a peer-reviewed article that is appropriate and within 5 years) The following matters must be discussed in the paper and presented in class: The author(s) of

Based on the feedback update the proposal you wrote. Please

Based on the feedback update the proposal you wrote. Please follow the guidance based on the attached documents. Please track changes in Word when editing your draft. You can go to Review – > Track Changes. You do not need to comment on where you added changes or why, just

Country Analysis for Amazon in Cameroon

Country Analysis: Essay Using the business (Amazon) and country (Cameroon) selected in Unit I, prepare a Word document of the political structure and economic environment, including important political events that may lead to success or high risk due to business expansion to that region. In a minimum of 500 words,

Controlling infectious diseases is part of public health practice. Review

Controlling infectious diseases is part of public health practice. Review approaches to prevention, control, and the obstacles that low-income and middle-income countries endure. Vaccines are a critical part of health, but health care systems are impacted by globalization. Some countries do not have surveillance systems in place that allow determining need. Provide an example of

Government and the Cyber Sector

Respond to each Individual Project Week 1 Individual Project – Overview of Cybersecurity Today The Executive Branch has inherent responsibilities to protect the nation and national infrastructure, including cyber networks and systems as well as the information that transits or is stored on that infrastructure. The theory of national policy-making

What you believe would be necessary to create a culture

What you believe would be necessary to create a culture that would be supportive of using research evidence in practice? Must address the topic. •Rationale must be provided. • May list examples from your own nursing practice. • 150-word minimum/250-word maximum without the references. • Minimum of two references

Disability expert paper on Dyslexia

You are to research the diagnosis (dyslexia) of the child and write minimally a 4-5 page paper that includes and expands on the following elements: definition of disability characteristics of disability causes of disability how the disability is diagnosed interventions/treatments/common adaptations for the disability other pertinent information (Defined as other