HSA 405 SU Healthcare Compliance Case Study Report Nursing Assignment Help

Overview

As a healthcare compliance medical-legal representative, you have been assigned to review a case on patient compliance and provide a report to the healthcare organization’s legal team. In this case, an infant-plaintiff alleged that obstetricians/gynecologists did not use proper care in their performance of a cesarean delivery, resulting in a brachial plexus injury in the infant.

Instructions

Read If a Patient Is Noncompliant, Can the OB/GYN Be at Fault? Then, write a 1–2 page report in which you:

  1. Analyze three main points relevant to the case. Consider if there were issues in explaining the injury, and whether the defense proved that the mother was noncompliant with the care recommended by her provider.
  2. Argue the case as to why you agree or disagree with the outcome providing three points to support your rationale.

Expert Solution Preview

Introduction:
In the case of alleged improper care leading to a brachial plexus injury in an infant during a cesarean delivery, it is important to analyze the relevant points and arguments presented. The following report will provide an analysis of three main points in the case and discuss the agreement or disagreement with the outcome, supported by three points.

1. Analysis of Three Main Points Relevant to the Case:
a. Issues in Explaining the Injury: One of the main points to consider is whether there were any issues in explaining the brachial plexus injury to the patient. Clear communication plays a critical role in ensuring patient understanding and informed decision-making. If the obstetricians/gynecologists failed to adequately explain the potential risks and complications associated with a cesarean delivery, it could impact the patient’s ability to make an informed choice. Furthermore, any complications specific to the brachial plexus injury, such as the potential long-term consequences, should have been thoroughly explained to the patient.

b. Defense’s Proof of Mother’s Noncompliance: Another significant point to analyze is whether the defense was able to prove that the mother was noncompliant with the care recommended by her provider. If medical records or other evidence indicate that the mother received clear instructions regarding post-operative care, such as limitations on lifting or proper wound care, and failed to comply, it could significantly impact the outcome of the case. The defense’s ability to provide convincing evidence of noncompliance or patient disregard for recommended care should be thoroughly evaluated.

c. Evaluation of Physician’s Standard of Care: It is crucial to assess whether the obstetricians/gynecologists adhered to the appropriate standard of care during the cesarean delivery. If it can be established that the medical professionals involved took all necessary precautions and followed established protocols, their actions may not be considered negligence. However, if deviations from standard practices are identified, it may strengthen the plaintiff’s case and increase the likelihood of finding fault with the medical practitioners involved.

2. Agreement or Disagreement with the Outcome:
Personally, I agree with the outcome of the case. My rationale is based on the following three points:

a. Lack of Adequate Explanation: If there were issues in properly explaining the injury to the patient, it could indicate a failure in informed consent. Patients have the right to be fully informed about the potential risks and complications associated with medical procedures to make informed decisions. If this communication was lacking, it supports the claim of improper care.

b. Absence of Convincing Evidence of Noncompliance: If the defense failed to provide strong evidence demonstrating essential noncompliance by the mother with recommended care, it weakens their position. The burden of proof lies with the defense to demonstrate that the patient was noncompliant and that this noncompliance directly contributed to the injury.

c. Standard of Care Deviations: If it can be established that the obstetricians/gynecologists did not adhere to the appropriate standard of care during the cesarean delivery, it further supports the outcome. Negligence in following established protocols and best practices can be indicative of a lack of proper care.

In conclusion, proper analysis of the main points and arguments presented in the case reveals the importance of clear communication, examination of patient compliance, and evaluation of the physician’s standard of care. Based on my assessment, I agree with the outcome of the case due to the lack of adequate explanation, the absence of convincing evidence of noncompliance, and potential deviations from the standard of care.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

I have assigned each of you a topic for your

  I have assigned each of you a topic for your ppt presentation. Due Date: Next Tuesday 10/11/22. It should be at least a minimum of 10 slides. Make sure you include an explanation of the diagnoses, signs/symptoms, nursing assessment, interventions/treatments and nursing diagnoses. Your are more than welcome to

Explain the impact that culture (slow/fixed) often has on the

1.      Explain the impact that culture (slow/fixed) often has on the development of technology (fast/fluid). Provide examples to support your claim. Evaluate whether the impact you describe is positive, negative, neutral or a mix of positive and negative. 2.      Describe the concept that is commonly referred to as “the myth

I am writing a paper on the Influence of Hip

   I am writing a paper on the Influence of Hip Hop music. The murdered of Tupac Shakur in particularly and the impact is had on the music industry. 10 page analysis of a significant historic/cultural event that has influenced human behaviors, human expression, ethics, and which you can analyze

Chemistry Web research

Do a web search on instrumentation for hazardous material identification used by Hazmat teams. For a starting reference see DHS Guide for the Selection of Chemical Detection Equipment for Emergency First Responders. Using the following chemicals: hydrochloric acid, anhydrous nitric acid (>70%) It is common practice it takes more than

Following the steps below, write a 3-4-page data analysis report.It

Following the steps below, write a 3-4-page data analysis report.It is important to include data excerpts in your report when analyzing and discussing your data. STEP-I: Watch the following two video clips. While watching, take notes on: • The situation, context, participants, etc. • Wallace’s use of certain words and

Write a 2-3 page article review in which you discuss

Write a 2-3 page article review in which you discuss privacy in the workplace. Introduction From an HR perspective, the topic of privacy in the workplace is often related to pre-employment background checks and the use of technology. During the pre-employment period, privacy can become a concern because employers investigate

Using the discussion preparation, choose two employment laws and examine

  Using the discussion preparation, choose two employment laws and examine the impact of each law on human resources management (HRM). Support your response with specific examples of each selected law’s impact on HRM. This is the discussion preparation link that must be used to answer the question: https://www.dol.gov/general/aboutdol/majorlaws

If you’ve ever read a book, listened to the radio,

If you’ve ever read a book, listened to the radio, or had basically any kind of human interaction, then you’ve already had a lot of experience with figurative language. If you were raised by wolves in the forgotten wilds of Ontario, you’ve never heard anything like it –get ready to

As discussed in lecture, Myanmar is going through a human

  As discussed in lecture, Myanmar is going through a human rights crisis now.  Watch the following video and write an 10 – 12 sentence paragraph about what is going on the this country.  Which ethnic group is being impacted?  Why is this happening?  What is genocide?  How is this

Please assist. Synthesize the previous work completed in Milestones One,

Please assist.  Synthesize the previous work completed in Milestones One, Two, and Three into your strategic health communication plan. The final submission should reflect the incorporation of feedback gained throughout the course. Develop a conclusion section for your proposal including the impact your public health media campaign will have on

Need only research methodologies for just 1 page Overview: The

  Need only research methodologies for just 1 page Overview: The term “abstract” is a homophone which can mean one of two scholarly writing activities. One, is the abstract that you will write to introduce your dissertation. The other meaning is a shortened writing assignment whereby you write a condensed

Select 5 primary research articles published in peer reviewed journals.

  Select 5 primary research articles published in peer reviewed journals. These should be the articles that  you have obtained from your literature search. Write a simple sentence  for each article to demonstrate your knowledge of formatting in-text citations using APA  guidelines. Then provide an APA-formatted reference list for the

A mother of a 6mo old has returned back to

  A mother of a 6mo old has returned back to work and is having trouble with pumping. She states that she is having less breast milk available. What recommendations should the Nurse Practitioner make? What is the most recent research about the benefits of breastfeeding?  What laws are in