HSA 5200 RU Bouvia vs Superior Court Case Analysis Nursing Assignment Help

Scenario

Analyze ethical and legal implications of cases involving bioethics. Two examples of highly publicized cases are listed below.

The national discussion concerning decision making for incompetent patients began with the 1976 case of Karen Ann Quinlan. Because she had been left in a persistent vegetative state after two periods of anoxia, her parents sought court authorization to remove her from a ventilator. The New Jersey Supreme Court, in a landmark, unanimous decision, authorized the removal based on Quinlan’s constitutional right of privacy, which the court concluded would be lost unless her parents were given authority to exercise it on her behalf. In the 15 years since Quinlan, courts in almost 20 states have reviewed disputes regarding treatment for incompetent patients. Courts in all these states have recognized the general right of competent people to refuse treatment, and in all but two states have also ultimately found that the U.S. Constitution, state constitution, or common law permits a surrogate to make treatment decisions on behalf of an incompetent person (Annas, 1990).

The case of Nancy Cruzan is essentially identical to that of Karen Ann Quinlan, with one exception: Nancy Cruzan, a young woman in a persistent vegetative state because of a 1983 automobile accident, requires only tube feeding (rather than a ventilator and tube feeding) to continue to survive. Her parents firmly believe she would not want to have tube feeding continued under such circumstances, in part based on her own statement that she would not want to continue to live if she could not be “at least halfway normal.” For this reason, a trial judge authorized her parents to have their daughter’s tube feeding discontinued (Annas, 1990).

Instructions

Select a case for which you are familiar or have an interest that involves medical ethics. Prepare a case analysis using the IRAC method. Your analysis should address the following:

The Issue

Rule

Analysis

Conclusion

Resources

  • Annas, George J, J.D., M.P.H. (1990). Sounding board: Nancy cruzan and the right to die. The New England Journal of Medicine, 323(10), 670-673.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Please respond to 2 peers My Post: The organizational structure,

Please respond to 2 peers My Post:   The organizational structure, which provides counsel to all employees, lays out the official reporting linkages that regulate the company’s workflow. A thorough diagram of a company’s structure makes it simple to hire more staff and gives a flexible and ready method of

Assessment of young children’s progress and achievements is ongoing, strategic,

  Assessment of young children’s progress and achievements is ongoing, strategic, and purposeful. The results of assessment are used to inform the planning and implementing of experiences, to communicate with the child’s family, and to evaluate and improve teachers’ and the program’s effectiveness. —Carol Copple and Sue Bredenkamp,Developmentally Appropriate Practice

QThe Health Information Technology for Economic Clinical Nursing Assignment Help

QThe Health Information Technology for Economic Clinical Health (HITECH) is one of several steps taken by the government to promote widespread implementation of health information technology (HIT). What other steps are being taken and what will be required for fully interoperable health information systems to become a reality?  You are

“Stories, stories everywhere” – Premium Paper Help

Premium Paper Help is a professional writing service that provides original papers. Our products include academic papers of varying complexity and other personalized services, along with research materials for assistance purposes only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references.

Tactics & Action

 Use the course materials to include articles, videos, and the module notes. The next sections for your marketing plan will be tactics (emarketing, for example), and the action phase of the plan. Both sections will bring a clearer insight into how the organization will begin to implement the strategies that

300 words List the signs and symptoms that point to

Premium Paper Help is a professional writing service that provides original papers. Our products include academic papers of varying complexity and other personalized services, along with research materials for assistance purposes only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references.

Search the Internet or Strayer Resource Center and provide an

Search the Internet or Strayer Resource Center and provide an example of a company that seems to be continually awarded contracts. Provide a logical analysis on why the company you researched seems to consistently “win” government contracts. Be specific in the steps that the company has “perfected” to ensure its

Zipcar offers a sophisticated form of car sharing (www.zipcar.com). The

  Zipcar offers a sophisticated form of car sharing (www.zipcar.com). The firm opened for business in Boston in late 2000. Describe the strategy of Zipcar using the six questions of Figure 4.2. Is the Zipcar strategy sustainable, and will it lead to profitability? Your response should be at least 300 words,

this is an example for it Dear Mr unknown, We

this is an example for it  Dear Mr unknown, We are pleased that it is you first time to work with us. As you know that we communicate with non-english speakers, so you have to know a bit of strategies to communicate with them politely. (1).(2).(3).(4).(5).  Please pay attention to

Living in Disadvantaged Neighborhoods is Bad for Your Health. http://www.unnaturalcauses.org/video_clips_detail.php?res_id=217

 Living in Disadvantaged Neighborhoods is Bad for Your Health. http://www.unnaturalcauses.org/video_clips_detail.php?res_id=217 Cardiologist David Weiland wonders why Gwai, a relatively young patient with no history of smoking, family heart disease, or other typical behavioral or genetic risk factors ended up having a heart attack. How does the film answer his question? Please include

After reading the article, think about how you can make

  After reading the article, think about how you can make and include a dignity board in your own classroom. It does not have to be titled “Dignity Board” but must meet the requirements of one. How you name it and present it will depend on which age group you

Hospital-acquired infections

”Scientific and Mathematical/Analytical Perspectives of Inquiry Paper” Compose a focused paper that explains and describes your healthcare issue/topic from the scientific and mathematical/analytical perspectives of inquiry. (You will cover two perspectives in one paper.) Address your general topic by forming and answering two levels of research questions for each inquiry.

To Prepare Review the interactive media piece for Nursing Assignment Help

To Prepare  Review the interactive media piece for Alzheimer’s Disease.  (76 Year Old Iranian Male) Reflect on the patient’s symptoms and aspects of the disorder presented in the interactive media piece. Consider how you might assess and treat patients presenting with the symptoms of the patient case study you were assigned. You

The write-ups will be slightly different from what you may have done

The write-ups will be slightly different from what you may have done in other courses. These write-ups should be typed, one-inch margins on all sides; 12 pt. Times New Romans; page numbers; single-space typed; and two pages (maximum length). This is not to be a review of the case. In

WGSS 1104: Feminisms in the Arts

 write a 2-page (double spaced) response to it. If citing specific images, pieces, or quotes, include them in a bibliography section using MLA formatting. Find and analyze a piece of writing that you feel exemplifies Virginia Woolf’s concept of “androgynous thinking”. This does not have to be a full text