Legal Reasoning

New York City Schools currently use standardized tests to determine who receives offers of admission to its Specialized High Schools. Mayor De Blasio has 1) reserved 20% of those 2019 offers for disadvantaged students who just missed the test-score cutoff for admission and 2) promised, pending state approval, to abolish the exam and base Specialized High School Admissions on ranking in the top 7% of Middle Schools, grades,, recommendations, and high school applications. Asian-Americans are currently suing to prevent Mayor De Blasio’s 2019 changes. Under the current system, at Stuyvesant High School, 1% of students are black. 3% are Hispanic. 18% are white and 74% are Asian. Nearly 70% of the entire New York City School System is black and Hispanic. Mayor De Blasio’s permanent solution to abolish the admissions test would probably decrease offers to Asian-American students by 50% and increase offers to black students to five times their current levels. Using two different stages of the four steps of legal reasoning, explain whether it is permissible for Mayor De Blasio to implement his first and second plans to change Specialized High School Admissions. Plan 1 (Legal Reasoning) Plan 2 (Legal Reasoning) In developing your rules or analysis, use at least one aspect of Grutter v. Bollinger 539 U.S. 306 (2003) AND/OR any other legal case.

#Legal #Reasoning

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

EXPERIMENTAL PROSPECTUS (Plant Project)

Produce a complete research prospectus for an experiment that you could actually carry out if you had the resources. Your prospectus should be written as if it would be submitted to the Research and Grants institutional review committee who would approve or deny your request to conduct the research. Your

Reflections on Child of Mine and Diabesity.

Child of Mine: read preface and chapters 1, 2, 7, 8, 9 and appendixes A,I,J,L, N,O,S Diabesity: READ THE ENTIRE BOOK In a 6-page, discuss your thought and reflections about Child of Mine and Diabesity. Compare and contrast the teaching within Child of Mine with the feeding practices of your

Scientific Study Analysis Prior to beginning work on this assignment,

Scientific Study Analysis Prior to beginning work on this assignment, read the article The Relationship Between Multiple Forms of Discrimination, Neighborhood Characteristics, and Depression Among Illicit Drug Users in New York CityLinks to an external site. and address the following questions in a three to four page (excluding title and reference pages)

Emotional Intelligence and Leadership: Part I What are your results?

 Emotional Intelligence and Leadership:   Part I What are your results?  Do you agree with them?  Why or why not? How is Emotional Intelligence connected to Leadership? Please provide an example of Emotional Intelligence/Leadership in the workplace. My score is 49. Your emotional intelligence level is…Ok. You probably have good relationships with

For your week One Cases/Questions Assignment, complete the following two

For your week One Cases/Questions Assignment, complete the following two Problem Solving Cases from Chapter Two and Three.Please submit your answers typed in a Word Document via the assignment link above by Sunday midnight in APA Format. Walmart’s Values Come under Scrutiny…Page 73 Read the Case Study entitled, “Walmart’s Values Come

1, Branches: Leap Year A year in the modern Gregorian

1, Branches: Leap Year A year in the modern Gregorian Calendar consists of 365 days. In reality, the earth takes longer to rotate around the sun. To account for the difference in time, every 4 years, a leap year takes place. A leap year is when a year has 366

Instructions Produce a complete 2-4 page paper in which you

  Instructions Produce a complete 2-4 page paper in which you do a comparison and contrast between driverless cars and/or traditionally driven cars. Be sure to define your reason for writing (thesis), and treat both ideas equally as to pros and cons, costs to promote, validity, efficiency to use, probability

Prepare an abstract that will describe your professional project as

Premium Paper Help is a professional writing service that provides original papers. Our products include academic papers of varying complexity and other personalized services, along with research materials for assistance purposes only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references.

Prompt Write a short memo explaining the significance of stakeholder

Prompt Write a short memo explaining the significance of stakeholder analysis. Specifically, you must address the following criteria: Describe the use of stakeholder analysis in organizational change management. How will the identities of different stakeholders influence their views on change initiatives? How can stakeholders encourage or inhibit change in an

Because a company-wide layoff is not routine, a leader would

Because a company-wide layoff is not routine, a leader would be more successful with face-to-face or phone communication. “Non-routine messages are often characterized by time pressure and surprise”. This is a non-routine message because company layoffs usually come as a surprise to everyone. It is extremely important for a leader

Problem -Solving Case: Cultural Diversity in a Cookie Factory.

 1. Explain why Lori Madden was hired as a consultant in the first place. 2. How did her role change after she spoke with the janitor? 3. Describe some of her findings and suggestions for the cookie production company. 4. Discuss some pro’s and con’s of addressing the diverse needs

I have assigned each of you a topic for your

  I have assigned each of you a topic for your ppt presentation. Due Date: Next Tuesday 10/11/22. It should be at least a minimum of 10 slides. Make sure you include an explanation of the diagnoses, signs/symptoms, nursing assessment, interventions/treatments and nursing diagnoses. Your are more than welcome to

Digital dashboard used for Business Intelligence.

Premium Paper Help is a professional writing service that provides original papers. Our products include academic papers of varying complexity and other personalized services, along with research materials for assistance purposes only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references.

Students will be required to write and submit an advocacy

   Students will be required to write and submit an advocacy letter to an advocacy collaborative on behalf of a devalued individual youth or group contending with systematic discrimination. You will need to clearly identify the person or group, explain the nature of the problem, and/or injustice, and articulate a