Report on a forensic evidence admissibility court case

Students must write one (1) report on a forensic evidence admissibility court case. Objective: Students need to demonstrate an understanding of evidence admissibility laws and how they evolve over time. The report should focus on the legal arguments of the cases. Formatting and length requirements: APA formatting and citation for any source used (see https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/section/2/10/ (Links to an external site.)Links to an external site. for a good APA guide). This includes a reference list and in-text citation. You do not need an abstract for this assignment. Every source you use, including the textbook, needs to be cited in your reference list. Each reference list entry must have a corresponding in-text citation. 12 pt. Times New Roman font. Double-spaced with 1-inch margins.

Three pages of content (750 words). Do not include your title page or reference list in your page count. Do not use excessive quotes. If you can re-state something in your own words, do so. You can go over this word count, if needed. Content: Select a case from the list below and write a short summary of the case. Answer the following: Who were the parties involved? What was the case about? What was the main legal issue and how was it resolved? What were the legal arguments? How did the case impact forensic evidence admissibility or expert testimony? Do some research and select a past or a more recent case that is related to your selected case. This case should relate to the rules of admissibility from your original case. For the case you select, be sure to answer the following: Who were the parties involved?

What was the case about? What was the main legal issue and how was it resolved? What were the legal arguments? How did the case impact forensic evidence admissibility or expert testimony? For a past case, answer at least one of the below questions: In what way did your selected case change/challenge (e.g. the past case allowed X but your case established X was not allowed or vice versa) the past case? OR in what way did your selected case build upon (e.g. past cases said a judge can only rule on established scientific techniques, but your case allowed judges to rule on both new techniques and established scientific techniques) the past case? For a more recent case, answer at least one of the below questions: How has the recent case built upon your selected case (e.g. a new technique was accepted as admissible evidence in the recent case because your selected case established the admissibility of the evidence)? OR how has the recent case changed/challenged your selected case (e.g. your selected case stated X was not admissible, but the recent case accepted X as admissible evidence)? Legal arguments: Be sure to concentrate on the legal arguments, both for and against changing the admissibility rule(s). Legal arguments against can be as simple as ‘this piece of evidence was never used before’, to arguments about the statistical sample used to prove the scientific technique, to questions about the validity of the method used. Legal arguments for can be as simple as ‘it has been used in another place by law enforcement agencies’, to ‘it has been used in courts before for X’, to proving the validity of the method used. Cases (pick one): Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993) (general admissibility) Andrews v. State of Florida, 533 So. 2d 841 Fla. Dist. Ct. App. (1988) (DNA) People v. Jennings, 252 Ill. 534, 96 N.E. 1077 (1911) (fingerprints) Selecting your research case: The research case should connect with one of the cases above in terms of rules of admissibility. So, if you select People v. Jennings, your research case should be centered around the admissibility of fingerprint evidence. In other words, for a more recent case, you need to find a case that either built upon the admissibility of fingerprint evidence or challenged the validity of fingerprint evidence. Alternatively, if you are using a past case, your research case needs to either be a basis for the legal arguments for or against the validity of fingerprint evidence. Your research case: SHOULD center around admissibility of evidence as a whole. For example, if you picked Andrews v. State of Florida, your research case should center on whether the court should trust the validity of DNA evidence or explored the validity of a new way of analyzing DNA evidence. SHOULD NOT be about the use of faulty evidence or about the rules of admissibility excluding inappropriate evidence. For example, the Mayfield case would be inappropriate as it is about the use of low quality fingerprint evidence, not the validity of fingerprint evidence. CAN be about the admissibility of a new technique. For example, your research case can be a case that focuses on the validity of a new way to collect or analyze DNA evidence if you pick Andrews v. State of Florida

#Report #forensic #evidence #admissibility #court #case

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Effective Team Communication Competency

Examine team member communication, collaboration, and strategies for developing team intelligence. Scenario Information As a leader, you have been tasked with building a team whose purpose is to recommend a new performance evaluation system. The current system is outdated and greatly reduces employee morale each year. Instructions As the leader

Chapter 5 of the textbook mentions the self-presentation theory. In

  Chapter 5 of the textbook mentions the self-presentation theory. In your own words, how would you define that theory? Then, based on the various types of online communities outlined in the textbook, from the list below, what online community would you identify yourself with and why? Communities of practice

The Super Hero Theme Park was started on January 1

 The Super Hero Theme Park was started on January 1 of the current year by Dr. Strange. The following selected events and transactions occurred during January: 1-Jan Jack Strange, the owner, invested $50,000 in the business. 5-Jan Purchased equipment for $100,000 on account from The Gotham Company. 8-Jan Incurred advertising

Questionnaire: 1-What are Genes? 2-Describe what a chromosome is and

  Questionnaire: 1-What are Genes? 2-Describe what a chromosome is and how are present normally in human beings? 3-Concepts for: Euploid cells, Diploid Cells, Aneuploid Cells? What is a Polyploidy? 4-What is a Trisomy and an example of it? 5-What means Homozygous and heterozygous in Mendelian Heritance? 6-Which are special

Hospital Administration: Electronic health record

Create a workflow diagram of data within an electronic medical record system. Make sure to explain the role of all important data points. Your workflow diagram must be a visual or graphical representation of the interaction of processes and/or how information (data) flows through an electronic medical record system for

If you owned a successful company, would you keep it

If you owned a successful company, would you keep it private or have it become a publicly-traded company?   A) If you go public and as the company grows,  would you prefer raising capital by issuing stock, bonds, or a combination of the two? Explain. B) If you decide not to go public,

Jack Welch, GE’s former CEO, said, “We now know where

  Jack Welch, GE’s former CEO, said, “We now know where productivity comes from. It comes from challenged, empowered, excited, rewarded teams of people.” Explain how group dynamics, team characteristics, team leadership, and team management all play a vital role in company productivity.  https://youtu.be/uG-FLOi4OOU 

Explain the six (6) main types of sampling (trial sample, convenience

Instructions for this assignment: Part A: Vocabulary words Define and provide one example for each; please include references 1.     Probability 2.     sample space 3.     sampling 4.     expected value of a probability distribution 5.     variance and the standard deviation of a probability distribution 6.     Poll 7.     Ethics Part B: 1.     Use

As a psychiatric nurse practitioner, it is essential for you

  As a psychiatric nurse practitioner, it is essential for you to have a strong background in foundational neuroscience. In order to diagnose and treat patients, you must not only understand the pathophysiology of psychiatric disorders but also how medications for these disorders impact the central nervous system. These concepts

Students will submit a written report of their data collection

 Students will submit a written report of their data collection findings and discuss the analysis of data. This should include a synopsis of the results, analysis methods used and a discussion of these findings. This assignment requires that you summarize how you will collect the data you will use for your research

How would you advise the management of the company to classify the

PART 1: a) Maddow and Wells, Inc. purchased equity securities in 2018. The management of the company has decided that the securities will not be sold immediately, but will be held for at least three years.  This will allow MW to maximize the potential gains from holding the securities. The

WU Health & Medical Creating a Drama Free Workplace Nursing Assignment Help

CREATING A DRAMA-FREE WORKPLACE The ways in which managers deal with—or fail to deal with—drama and negativity in the workplace have far-reaching effects on the overall organizational culture. The average professional spends a significant portion of their lives in the workplace, so it would be sensible to ensure that it

Refer to “Eli Lilly: Recreating Drug Discovery for the 21st

Refer to “Eli Lilly: Recreating Drug Discovery for the 21st Century.” This assignment uses a rubric. Please review the rubric prior to beginning the assignment to become familiar with the expectations for successful completion. Doctoral learners are required to use APA style for their writing assignments. The APA Style Guide

For this assignment, explore the different types of leadership styles.

  For this assignment, explore the different types of leadership styles. In a 10-12-slide PowerPoint discuss which approaches are most effective for a health care setting and why. For the presentation of your PowerPoint, use Loom to create a voice-over or a video. Refer to the Topic Materials for additional

You are doing a clinical rotation in a family practice

You are doing a clinical rotation in a family practice setting. You have been assigned to follow Ms. K through her visit to the primary care provider. As you complete your interview with Ms. K, she asks whether you can answer some questions. She says, “I have a lot of

Comparative Report on Financial Markets

Select four financial markets from any one of the following regions: a. Middle East b. Asia c. Europe d. Africa f. America ( SELECT AMERICA PLEASE ) 3. Study each of the selected market and compare them on the following basis. You can use table, graph or any other comparative