To what extent do you think Jonathan Turner’s (1985; 1992) defence of

Overview: Jonathan Turner is a prominent American sociologist, who is known for his contributions to the history of sociology, the sociology of religion and of emotions, and to the general theoretical practice of sociology, in the mid to late 20th century. Turner also defends the a form of ‘positivism’ in the social sciences, arguing that it is the positivist approach to sociology that secures its status as a science, notwithstanding the differences between methods and theories employed in the social and natural sciences. In several articles (Turner, 1985; Turner, 1992), Turner directly defends the legacy and contemporary contributions of positivism to social science from a variety of criticisms. In this essay, you will be discussing various criticisms of the ‘positivist’ approach to social science, and looking at the way that Turner responds to those criticisms. You will need to decide if you generally agree with Turner and his ‘positivist’ sociology, or if you are persuaded by the critics of contemporary positivist social science.  

 

What you need to do in this essay: This essay can be broken down into four main ‘tasks’:  

·        
Accurately summarise Turner’s views of ‘positivism’ (paying attention to his definition of positivism, his views on ‘science’, his concept of scientific theory, his ideas about theoretical and historical explanations) and his responses to criticisms of positivist social science.

·        
Accurately summarise the criticisms of positivism put forward by Bryant (1992) and Riley (2007), and any other additional criticisms or appraisals of ‘positivist’ social science / sociology you have read in the additional readings;

·        
Clearly identify areas of disagreement (and/ or misunderstanding) between the critics and defenders of positivist social science (these may include, but are not limited to: the definition of positivism; the definition of science and social science; the idea of theory; the use of evidence in the sciences; the applicability of natural scientific method to social science; the real-world ‘effects’ of positivist ideas).

·        
Clearly answer the question: is Turner’s defence of positivism successful? (e.g. is it convincing? Does it show the usefulness of a positivist approach or positivist ideas to contemporary social science? Does it show the criticisms of positivism are wrong?)               

 

 

Notes on the Readings:  You are required to read and make reference to the essential readings. These are the two articles by Turner (1985; 1992), and the articles by Bryant (1992) Fuller (1992), and Riley (2007). Note that the three articles – Turner (1992), Bryant (1992) and Fuller (1992) are part of a direct debate about positivism: Bryant’s article is a critique of the ideas of Gerhard Lenski, Guy Swanson and Jonathan Turner; Turner and Fuller then responded to Bryant’s arguments.      

 

Note on the Additional Readings: Baldus (1990), Howe (2009), Ferrarotti (1999), and Brieschke (1992) all provide criticisms of positivism. Lundberg (1939), Schlick & Rynin (1948/49) and Taube (1937) and Laird (1938-9) give ‘classic’ (non-comtemporary) discussions of positivism, attempting to define and exemplify the positivist approach. Other readings on the list talk about positivism and various philosophical approaches to studying society (see: Rickman, 1960; Oberdan, 1990; Warshay & Warshay, 1987), or positivism as a ‘methodology’ (see: Dugger, 1983; Neufeld, 1993; Chenhall, 1971).     

 

Essential Readings

Bryant, Joseph M. (1992). ‘Positivism Redivivus? A Critique of Recent Uncritical Proposals for Reforming Sociological Theory (And Related Foibles)’, The Canadian Journal of Sociology / Cahiers canadiens de sociologie, Vol. 17, No. 1 (Winter, 1992), pp. 29-53

Fuller, Steve (1992). ‘A Plague on Both Your Houses: Beyond Recidivism in the Sociological Theory Debates’. The Canadian Journal of Sociology / Cahiers canadiens de sociologie, Vol. 17, No. 1(Winter, 1992), pp. 62-68

Turner, Jonathan H. (1985). In Defense of Positivism, Sociological Theory, Vol. 3, No. 2 (Autumn, 1985), pp. 24-30

Turner, Jonathan H. (1992). If Not Positivism, Then Why Is Sociology Important? The Canadian Journal of Sociology / Cahiers canadiens de sociologie, Vol. 17, No. 1 (Winter, 1992), pp. 54-61.

Riley, Dylan (2007). The Paradox of Positivism, Social Science History, Vol. 31, No. 1 (Spring, 2007), pp. 115-126

Click here to request for this assignment help

#extent #Jonathan #Turners #defence

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

senegal – Premium Paper Help

Premium Paper Help is a professional writing service that provides original papers. Our products include academic papers of varying complexity and other personalized services, along with research materials for assistance purposes only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references.

3070 Teacher Interview APA Template (Word Doc) Actions Taskstream Part

  3070 Teacher Interview APA Template (Word Doc) Actions Taskstream Part 1. Interview with Teacher Conduct a detailed interview either with a general or a special education teacher about how she/he works with parents to support student learning for students with disabilities. Instructions: Conduct an interview with a teacher (special education

Since Text 1 for Project 3, the written genre, is

Since Text 1 for Project 3, the written genre, is persuasive, you are going to be making an argument in that first text.  For this assignment,  you should first read Chapter 16 “Strategies for Supporting an Argument” on pages 339-361 in our textbook. This chapter outlines different strategies that writers

Many online news and information platforms allow us to vote

  Many online news and information platforms allow us to vote on the content, noting what we click on, what we like, and what we ignore. As we provide this information, self-segmentation can occur over time. We may only be shown those news and entertainment stories that are most likely

Themes that went along with the lives and struggles of African

The 10-page length is minimal and does not include title page, endnotes, or bibliography. No quotes longer than 2 typed sentences are allowed. Papers need to be drawn from a minimum of six independent primary documents and six secondary sources. Primary documents can be taken from online sources. Your secondary

Suppose that you are asked to choose between Med-Arb and

Premium Paper Help is a professional writing service that provides original papers. Our products include academic papers of varying complexity and other personalized services, along with research materials for assistance purposes only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references.

Understanding and using financial ratios is a key method by

Understanding and using financial ratios is a key method by which analysts determine company value and long-term sustainability.  Select a publicly-traded company of your choosing.  Use their annual report or other information to: Share some of the financial ratios you have found Share some of the trends you see Provide

The importance and impact of diversity in telecommunications

The purpose of this assignment is to (1) learn more about the importance and impact of diversity in telecommunications and (2) practice conducting research and using proper source citation.   1, Find a current scholarly research article or book chapter published after 2013 that examines diversity in telecommunications (mass media,

A Comparison of the Legal Systems For this week’s assignment,

  A Comparison of the Legal Systems For this week’s assignment, you will evaluate criminal justice systems via the webpage Guide to International and Foreign Law Research (Links to an external site.). Across the globe, there are various types of law including civil law, Muslim law, common law, customary law, and

Jane, a military psychologist, wants to examine two types of

Jane, a military psychologist, wants to examine two types of treatments for depression in a group of military personnel who have suffered the loss of their legs. She has only 20 men to work with. What would be the best research design for the study and why? What are some

Reply1Ethical dilemma is a decision-making problem between two possible moral imperatives,neither of which is unambiguously acceptable or preferable .One action must be chosen, thereby generating a qu Nursing Assignment Help

Reply1 Ethical dilemma is a decision-making problem between two possible moral imperatives,neither of which is unambiguously acceptable or preferable .One action must be chosen, thereby generating a quandary for the person or group who is burdened with the choice. Example,the ethical dilemma which was encountered is in line of patient

You must submit 3 cybersecurity project proposals with the topic

You must submit 3 cybersecurity project proposals with the topic being 50-100 words and five milestones being 25-50 words each. I can’t think of any good project ideas along with 5 steps explaining what and how I will be completing the project. Please try to think of easy ones. This

Identify and describe the range of physical, cognitive, language,

Learning Objectives 1) Identify and describe the range of physical, cognitive, language, moral, and social-emotional development of individuals from conception through adolescence. 3) Apply the developmental theories of Piaget, Vygotsky, Erikson, B.F. Skinner, Bronfenbrenner, and/or Bandura to analyze instructional activities and student behavior. 5) Apply their knowledge of effects of

After reviewing and studying this module’s content, answer the following

  After reviewing and studying this module’s content, answer the following questions. Be sure to complete all lab activities and attend/watch all live lectures before completing this assignment. All of your answers should be written in your own words, using full sentences, correct terminology, and proper spelling and grammar. Explain

HIMA 460 AMU Carilions Data Governance Journey Discussion Nursing Assignment Help

The following video, led by Carilion’s CMIO, describes the steps and challenges Carilion Healthcare System faced in implementation of a data governance program. What do you think caused data quality issues at Carilion? How does the data governance organizational structure at Carilion compare to that presented in your readings? What